What radiometric dating technique is used to date volcanic rock

Posted by / 28-Jun-2017 14:01

What radiometric dating technique is used to date volcanic rock

Even when the calculated error margins are taken into account the different radioisotope dating methods yield completely different "ages" that cannot be reconciled—1240±84 Ma (Rb-Sr), 1655±40 Ma (Sm-Nd), and 1883±53 Ma (Pb-Pb) (see diagram).None of the obtained isochron "ages" corresponds to the "date" for any recognized event, neither the original lava eruptions nor the subsequent metamorphism.Yet the discordance patterns are consistent with past accelerated radioisotope decay, which would also render these "clocks" useless.Thus there is no reliable evidence to dispute that these metamorphosed basalt lava flows deep in Grand Canyon date back to the Creation Week only thousands of years ago.And the K-Ar model "ages" are so widely divergent from one another (ranging from 405.1±10 Ma to 2574.2±73 Ma), even from very closely spaced samples from the same outcrop of the same original lava flow, as to be useless for "dating" any event.These discordant results could easily be dismissed as an isolated aberration, perhaps due to the uncertain effects of metamorphism and any subsequent alteration, especially during erosion and weathering.In other words, the decay of the parent radioisotopes was accelerated by different amounts, the decay of those yielding older "ages" (the alpha-decayers) having been accelerated more.

Clearly visible in the canyon walls are the light-colored granites, such as the Zoroaster Granite, which are stark against the darker, folded strata of the Vishnu Schist and the other metamorphic rock units of the Granite Gorge Metamorphic Suite (see lowest purple and green shading in diagram).

Irreconcilable disagreement within and between the methods is the norm, even at the outcrop scale.

This is a devastating "blow" to the long ages that are foundational to uniformitarian geology and evolutionary biology.

The computer program Isoplot was used to plot isochrons and calculate isochron ages from the other radioisotope analyses.

The best isochron plots, where all the variation from the line of best fit to the data incorporates all the analytical errors, yielded an Rb-Sr isochron age of 1240±84 Ma, an Sm-Nd isochron age of 1655±40 Ma, and a Pb-Pb isochron age of 1883±53 Ma.

what radiometric dating technique is used to date volcanic rock-79what radiometric dating technique is used to date volcanic rock-47what radiometric dating technique is used to date volcanic rock-15

It is also claimed that the original basalt lavas were erupted between 17 Ma, based on U-Pb dating of "original" zircon grains in metamorphosed felsic (granitic) volcanic layers within the Brahma and Rama Schists.

One thought on “what radiometric dating technique is used to date volcanic rock”

  1. Não se trata apenas de criticar ou elevar o pequeno almoço de um hotel, o preço da entrada de um museu ou de descrever um lugar pitoresco, aqui partilhamos experiências de vida com o desejo de que outras pessoas aproveitem e desfrutem os nossos descobrimentos e evitem cometer os mesmos erros.